Not signed in (Sign In)
    •  
      CommentAuthorNorganna
    • CommentTimeOct 2nd 2009
     
    As you may know, for the past few months I have been taking a break from the daily grind of being "norganna". I have actually been involved in some of my other projects for this time, and I'm finally ready to come back and have a good look at the future of Auctioneer.

    The current state of affairs is that we have 4 servers running. One of which is reasonably expensive and for all intents and purposed is dedicated to running AuctioneerDb.

    The remaining 3 other servers, are for the Auctioneer development, issue tracking, wikis, forums, email etc.

    Just a bit of background. AuctioneerDb was meant to be a collaborative price database. It was something that many people doggedly asked for over the life of the Auctioneer project, and I have sunk quite a bit of my own time and money (2 years of my spare time, and around $5000 of my own money at this point) into the project to find out that almost nobody is going to use it. We got during the peak of it's use about 100 visitors/day.

    It's a terrible shame to me, thinking that I'm going to have to shut it down and admit failure. Worse, I feel foolish for even taking on this project to start with, which is something that I've been coming to terms with over the last several months.

    I've decided to put out the decision to you guys. If enough of you make a commitment to use it, tell people about it, make donations so that we can continue it, then I'll make a commitment to bring it up to date, get everything back up and running and fund it for the next 6 months even if it is partially coming out of my own pocket to pay for the servers. At the end of the 6 months, we should have enough traffic and data, that with a proportion of the user base as subscribers to the service can cover at least the cost of the servers.

    If not, then I will simply have to face the fact that it's a failure. Sometimes you just can't see things objectively from the inside.

    If you want to pledge your support, make a post in this article and tell some other people you know about what's going on.

    Thanks, norganna.
    •  
      CommentAuthorMattBnr
    • CommentTimeOct 2nd 2009 edited
     
    If everyone donated $1 we could keep it alive. Think about it, Auctioneerheads of the world unite!
    • CommentAuthorAmkae
    • CommentTimeOct 3rd 2009
     
    I have only been playing wow for a few months. During that time I have found Auctioneer to be a stable and reliable Db. It will be a loss if it simply disappears into the abyss of what-once-was. I enjoy the opportunity to play my game without camping in the AH for hours.

    Thank you for your dedication. I support your work and your staff and have posted a request on the official WoW (NA) forum.
    Future of Auctioneer: A dead addon?
    I have posted a thread to gamers requesting supporters to take a moment to visit this forum and provide feedback.
    •  
      CommentAuthordinesh
    • CommentTimeOct 3rd 2009 edited
     
    Just to clarify - as far as I know, norgs is only talking about AuctioneerDB, the new offline price database collector. There are no plans to discontinue the core Auctioneer suite at this time.
    •  
      CommentAuthorkostermw
    • CommentTimeOct 3rd 2009
     
    Well, to be honoust ... I tried it a few times and it failed. So I thought; "better wait a while and come back in a few weeks to see if it is fixed"

    Also, when I enter the site, it is not realy clear where to download and how to install, (or even that it exist) and since I use 'curse' now I expect all addons which are worthwile do install from curse. AuctioneerDB is not there (yet)
    • CommentAuthorArmedallo
    • CommentTimeOct 3rd 2009
     
    I would have been using it, however my server is not included within the search parameters.

    Server Illidan just does not exist.
    •  
      CommentAuthorMattBnr
    • CommentTimeOct 3rd 2009
     
    for info to exist a user has to first use the database then upload the file. it doesn't come pre installed with data. we don't have enough people to scan every server on each faction.
    • CommentAuthorRiveth
    • CommentTimeOct 3rd 2009
     
    I think it is a great tool, and have been uploading for a while, but needs better promotion. I don't know how much load the server can handle, but maybe getting it linked from some popular sites would help. Maybe wowwiki?
    •  
      CommentAuthorMattBnr
    • CommentTimeOct 3rd 2009 edited
     
    I agree. i think its a great way to get data for a server especially if you doing a transfer or something so you don't have to start all new. It does need more promotion too but just how to go about it is another thing. Perhaps your right maybe on the auctioneer page of curse we could add a link to the aucdb site and maybe on wowinterface. maybe start a auctioneer page on Facebook as i know lots of people use that service. maybe start a auctioneer Twitter page. Throw in some Myspace and right there you got the 3 major networks covered. Maybe get a review on one of the major wow sites around.
  1.  
    Work a little PR magic and you could probably get hosted on G4 ;-)

    I personally love everything about Auctioneer. However, you have to admit, it takes some effort understand how to get it set up. How did Bill Gates become one of the most wealthy men in the world (besides backstabbing and manipulation)? Taking a good idea and tailoring it to the common user. I'm not sure how but I believe the complexity of the program is what keeps some people from it.

    So in a nutshell some good PR and simplification should smooth all this over.
    •  
      CommentAuthorMattBnr
    • CommentTimeOct 3rd 2009
     
    well its not the main auctioneer that's the problem its aucdb.
    • CommentAuthorallaei
    • CommentTimeOct 3rd 2009
     
    This was the first time I've heard of this part of auctioneer.. Perhaps some more PR could definitely help. Maybe wow.com or other such wow sites. They get tons of traffic and it's an easy way to get the word out.

    I downloaded and tried to use the AucDb, and I'm getting an error when I try to use it:
    Warning:
    Unexpected exception caught.
    Message:
    Error in AddByte(CacheItem47529Slot): value (76658) exceeds byte size
    • CommentAuthorMonk
    • CommentTimeOct 3rd 2009
     
    I find the idea compelling but to be honest I just don't understand what it is. Is it something I can use in game?
    •  
      CommentAuthorMattBnr
    • CommentTimeOct 3rd 2009
     
    It is a project similar to wowecon except it uses the data you collect while scanning. the data is then uploaded to the servers and processed so you can see the data on the server in a graph if you so choose to. Yes you can also use it in game. as its a pricing model from everyone that uploads their files its a pretty good average price to go by. As of now aucdb is out of commission which is why you are getting a error when trying to use it.
    • CommentAuthorstihor
    • CommentTimeOct 3rd 2009
     
    I had not heard of this. I love Auctioneer and I and my folks would be glad to contribute and join, tell me what I need to do. I really did not hear that it existed.
    •  
      CommentAuthornormal
    • CommentTimeOct 3rd 2009
     
    I tend to agree the visibility issue's the major problem. QuestHelper has a load time printout that says 'Hey we need your data!'. Can't see why AuctioneerDB couldn't do similar. That way, when people load it up via their standard Auctioneer install, they see it. Also, mentioning it on the Curse/WoWI/Norganna pages as well would be good.
    • CommentAuthorRiveth
    • CommentTimeOct 3rd 2009
     
    Two ideas:

    • What about having auctioneer suggest auctioneer db?
      [*]Maybe work on the auctioneerdb website design a little... 99designs and crowdSPRING seem like options if we can get a little money, unless there is a designer in house
    • CommentAuthorwotch
    • CommentTimeOct 3rd 2009
     
    Norganna,
    It distresses me to read how you feel about Db and yourself, neither are justified, although understandable given your hopes for it and the lack of response. As you have provided myself and others with the benefit and pleasure of using Auctioneer over years, you never need to feel any shame about any project you attempt.

    Db has its own problems and may not be working atm. Despite that I use it and upload often anyway. I scan more often to ensure that I will upload the best data possible. Foolish?: No. Any of your effort deserves the best I can do to support something you believe is worthwhile.

    I want it to work for me and you, in ignorance I had no idea of the personal commitment you invest. The day I stumbled over Db I stopped using Wowecon, because I owe that to both of us.

    Why? As a senior who loves Wow and has used Auctioneer and all your other addons for years, it has allowed me to play solo and still accumulate funds to buy reasonable gear. I delight in auctioning at 95% when the greedy and mean are at 260%, so that someone who is struggling may get benefit from our efforts. I am aware that your associates must also commit lots of time to support the maintenance, development and updating of these addons, and they can take a big bow.

    No one ever knows what effort and foolish endeavors will achieve, so up on your hind legs and make that upload problem go away. At least then you will have usable data and supporters have no excuse not to use it. Alternatively bin all of it, not just Db so that I'll spend more time levelling and not having toons winging about lack of excitement.

    This isn't a joke, I expose my feelings once a decade. Get on with what I couldn't do in 10 lifetimes, you will gain something of use for the rest of your life, certainly honour and respect. I wasted many years avoiding potential failure, and can never regain them.

    Bless you Norganna , now I've discovered crying

    My highest respect and best wishes
    Michael N
    • CommentAuthorSolder
    • CommentTimeOct 3rd 2009
     
    Not to put too fine a point on this, but I'd never heard of auctioneerdb until this very second. Is it advertised somewhere? I don't see any links to it anywhere, and I've never looked at the forums until just now.


    I'm betting very few people KNOW about it.
    • CommentAuthorGrina
    • CommentTimeOct 4th 2009
     
    I was not aware of the expences involved in AucDB.

    I too deleted WOWEcon when I learned of AucDB, but after a week of not being able to get the it to work for me, I was forced to reinstall the othe Econ. I had assumed that when AucDB was ready for prime time, the word would go out, it would get uploaded to Curse and it would work.

    To be brutaly honest, I only notice the addon's existance by chance and if it had been any other author then you, I wouldn't have taken the time to track down the scant amount of information describing the tool. It took me longer then it should have to actually find the download. I have no idea if I was even using it right. I found no useful documentation (either with the tool or in the wiki) and the only feedbackI get from the tool (that anything is actually happening) was when I would get errors (it's alltogeather possible that the tool is functional and the errors were directly related to my not having any detailed direction on how to setup and work the tool. ).

    I love (and use) all your addons, they are superior to any of the others out there and also because they all "just work" right out of the box...AucDB,currently, isn't and doesn't.

    It this point, I believe the choice come down to:

    a) If you intend to keep AucDB with it's current level of PR, usability, documentation and unfunctionality...scrap it, don't continue to waste resources, because no one will use it.
    or
    b) If you feel you have the time and motivation to 1) Actually tell people about the tool, 2) make the tool intuative to use (or at least provide detailed setup and usage directions) and 3) have the tool actually work (or if it does work and I was just using it wrong, see #2)...then yes, I think this could be a Great tool that allot of people would use (and probably pay to use...Wowecon does it and they suck).

    Now I know most of my post has been pretty negitive and I'm sorry. I am not trying flame or put you or your work down. I was just trying to explain (as I see it) the realities of the situation.


    From your post, you seem to have two main problems 1) no one is using the tool and 2) it's costing a butt load of money. I will try to provide some suggestions (take it or leave it) on how I think you could address these problems.

    Marketing:
    People need to know the tool actually exists. A post on your main page (that will be pushed down at the next Auctioneer update) is not going to cut it. Update your Curse pages for all your addons with information about this new tool. Maybe talk to other addon writers and ask if they will post a small blurb about your tool and you could do the same for them.
    Next, you are very smart in development and economics (and probably other things I don't know about) but some (possibly most) of your users are not. When you explain the tool, you need to explain, in fairly simple terms. This will basically set the hook (you can get into the OMGWTF 1337 Macro Economics speak, later, to reel them in). How will the tool benefit them, make their life easier or help them make more gold, faster.
    The Key is: Make a Need in the reader's mind and then show how your programs can Satisfy that Need better then anything else out there. If you make that Need compeling enough, they will even pay to have that Need satified.

    Documentation:
    More Documentation! Specific Steps on how to setup and use the tool ( that actually match up with the current build of the tool)

    Optional/lower priority: I have read thru most of the information available for most of your addons. They are sometimes not up-to-date with the current feature set of the addon they are describing ( which is common, you don't have time updateing all the FAQs, Wiki pages and curse addon pages after every release) and even if they are up-to-date they (specificly the Auctioneer docs and tool tips) tend to assume the reader is proficent in Economics and it's vocabulary. That is fine, allot of the people that come here do seem to know that stuff, but to reach the less knowelgable, you need to start out explaining things in mildly simpler terms (example: you know what a "mean value" is without even thinking. you would hope that others know as well, but you may need to give a simple explination or use more "laymens terms). I marked this as optional/low priority because all your addon (except AucDB) are pretty easy to use and usually work (for non-advanced users) right out of the box.

    Usability:
    As I mentioned, most of your addons are fairly easy to use (at least in using the addon's basic functionality). In my humble opinion, AucDB is not. I highly recommend designing the tool to be more user friendly. make each pregressive step or function obvious to the users. (Example: After every user action, it's good to have confirmation (a sound or visual indication that something has occured and the tool has acknowledged it)
    The best way, I have found, to test usability (without actually standing over a bunch of new users recourding how they fumble thru your program) is to imagine I am my father or mother (or some other no computer literate relitive) and try to figure out how they would go about using the tool. If you come to something that you think they wouldn't understand or know what to do next, you know you need to improve the Usability of that part of the tool.

    Money
    Call out for help from the community. You have (arguably) some of the most populare addons available. Overtly asking (once in a while) for money is not a bad thing...do it too much and it will turn people off. But in emergencies (such as this) explain what is happening (like you did in this thread) and then ask for monitary assistance!

    (note: the key is to explain why it's more importent for the reader to donate now, then is normally. True, making all your addons should warrant a donation all the time, but explaining the situation will usually set a fire under the reader butt, to donate now)


    Anyways, I've rambled on enough, but I hope you find something useful in what I have writen (and badly spelled). Most of my post may have been on the negitive side, but only because I genuinely what you to make the choice that best benifits You. (because if too many bad things happen to you, I might just loss my precious Gatherer and Auctioneer and well playing WoW without them...ack!...best not to think of that disaster :-)

    Thanks again for all your effort,
    Grina
    • CommentAuthorApaseall
    • CommentTimeOct 4th 2009 edited
     
    Got to agree with the above posts.

    1 Get it working.
    2 Document it.
    3 Market it.

    There is simply no point in doing anything with it in terms of 2 or 3 if it does not work.
    Think of like a 12 year old, make it stuipidly simple to find, install and use.

    If they don't know what it is, where it is, how to install it or how to use it and if when they do it does not work then I would give up. Your wasting our time, theirs and yours.
    The time and effort folks put into auctioneer is phenominal. If something breaks it, it gets attention right away. Try the same with AucDB.

    Documentation is a VERY important thing. What is the point of being a genius delivering an outstanding product if you cannot be bothered to tell users how to use it. Better of staying in bed.

    I'll mention it here again, give us an option to properly support dev work by allowing recurring donations, i.e. paypal setup to send you $1 a month without having to manually make the payment each time. Thats not for AucDb but for ALL dev work. Before you say it's not possible ::: that is how I pay my monthly subscription for WOW :::
    • CommentAuthorFred
    • CommentTimeOct 4th 2009
     
    I did not know AucDB even existed until a few weeks ago.
    When I tried it, I got errors.

    I'd like to try it once it is working.
    • CommentAuthorApaseall
    • CommentTimeOct 4th 2009
     
    On the subject of donations, please please breed the paypal donate button, I only visit the forums regularly & I don't see one around here to click (might have missed it to be sure).
    • CommentAuthorkrendar
    • CommentTimeOct 4th 2009
     
    I agree with some of the above posters that it has not been "marketed" properly. I have hardly seen anybody in the UI forums at wow-europe.com mention it despite they know all sorts of obscure addons.

    Regarding the server-cost I can imagine it can be expensive. I have a few suggestions, don't know how feasible they are:

    1. Talk to people at the large wow-sites. Perhaps they can see a good idea to sponsor such project. (I am thinking of sites like Wowhead, curse, etc).

    2. Would it be possible to build-in some sort of peer-to-peer function in the Wowdb client? I am sure Norganna wouldn't have to implement it all since there is probably some plug'n play torrent kit for developers somewhere. Now, obviously we can't demand anyone to share since some people got limited bandwidth and some people even pay hourly for access. But if I could have a constantly updated databased installed locally I would surely keep the client running in the background :)
    • CommentAuthorAydrien
    • CommentTimeOct 4th 2009
     
    Up until aucdbsync stopped working, I was uploading data almost every day for my realm and several of my guildmates were using the db site to check prices when I wasn't on. Since I can't update the site anymore though, they've stopped using it (as have I). However, I'm sure that if it were working again, we'd go back to using it.

    It's a great idea, and a very well executed one. I check the front page pretty often hoping there's an update to when it will be fixed.

    But I understand the personal cost and the time that goes into maintaining all these addons and the sites that go with them, especially when a patch can unexpectedly break it all over night. Gotta take care of yourself first, you know? If you feel like it's more work than it's worth, then let it go and don't look back.

    If you want to have another go at it, please let us know if there's something we can do to help and to make it less of a burden to maintain everything. Donations have already been mentioned (I'll go look for the donation button after my next paycheck), but if there's anything else we can do too, let us know.
    • CommentAuthorwotch
    • CommentTimeOct 4th 2009
     
    Just donated, I feel better now!!

    Norganna, these people obviously care about you and your work, now back to the workbench with a smile
  •  
    I agree with the above in that more visibility is needed. This is the first I heard of AucDB while checking for updates to Auctioneer.
    Also, would it be possible to get mobile apps developed? I understand mobile devices, like my Android based phone have a web browser to access the site, but a specific app would be nice. If the DB interface is well documented I could whip something up for the Android platform
    • CommentAuthormahigral
    • CommentTimeOct 5th 2009
     
    Hi,

    Shamed into Donating by your post as it's too easy to take for free and I'd hate you to give up the good work.

    Agree with most of the comments - visibility and simplicity of use/install are key. Stumbled accross DB and started to use until upload broke. How to get/Instructions/Downloads etc. (for all the addons) should be simpler.

    Brilliant tools - keep up the good work - please :-)
    • CommentAuthorLoxado
    • CommentTimeOct 5th 2009
     
    This new AucDB is useful for people that start new with Auctioneer, or have a long time no scans. Am I getting this correct?

    What use is AucDB for people that scan the AHA 2-3 times a day VERY regularly?

    Or am I missing the point of AucDB completely?

    I confess I did not pay any attention to WOWecon or AucDB as I think my auctioneer data for this server is very accurate and every input from the outside could just ruin my data - maybe I am awfully incorrect in this assumption!

    I do care very much about Auctioneer and I am sure the work (and money of course - 5k US$ is a tremendous amount!!) Norganna put into the new AddOn has its value - but maybe the people that do visit this site are the wrong audience for the advertisment because most of us do scan very regularly to get accurate data (if my assumption in my first sentence is correct). Advertisement needs to be on buffed.de, curse.com, WOWAce.com,....
    •  
      CommentAuthordinesh
    • CommentTimeOct 5th 2009 edited
     
    If you are happy with your current stats, AucDB may not be of much use to you.

    But its goal is to provide more accurate statistics which approximate the true "highest sellable price" point for an item. All of our other stats try to estimate that price by looking at the prices items are listed for. AucDB instead reports the prices that items actually sell for. This latter thing is not available to you in game (at least, for anything other than your own sales). AucDB allows us to aggregate that date for multiple sellers on a realm.

    It also provides an offline mechanism for querying this data, which some people might find useful.
    • CommentAuthorkezmoo
    • CommentTimeOct 5th 2009 edited
     
    Hi, I've just come back to WoW after a long break, and the first thing I did was head here!

    I love the idea of AucDB, so although I've not had a chance yet, I'm happy to stick my hand up and say "I'm in"!

    And yes, you probably do need a bit more PR - maybe we should start spamming the trade channels! ;)

    (Now, wouldn't be nice if we could also track all those WTS and WTB messages as well...)

    Oh, and while the people that visit this site may not be the best audience, aren't they likely to be the best contributors, making it more useful (and useable) for those people who are?
    • CommentAuthorRiamus
    • CommentTimeOct 6th 2009 edited
     
    Well, I did know about it because I always check the Auctioneer and Gatherer news pages and I saw it when it went live and even heard about it before then. That said, I had no real idea what it was good for. Without details on how it works or anything, I just looked at the site itself. It let me enter an item and get a price for a realm (not my main realm though). As far as I could tell from that, it was simply a way to check prices offline. From my point of view looking at that, it was not worthwhile to use as I could look at prices while I'm playing inside the game itself with Auctioneer. Why bother leaving the game and looking online? That was my view and I never looked again until now. And even now, that's the same feeling I get when I look at the site. There isn't anything that remotely tells me it's useful for anything else. Only from reading this thread did I find out that there is a downloadable part to it that lets you view pricing in the game itself. Only from reading this thread did I even find out there was a downloadable part that lets you upload data.

    Simply put as most everyone has pointed out, there is virtually no description or instructions or readily available download link for AucDB that helps someone decide to use it in the first place. Without that, I'm surprised there are even 100 hits/day.

    Put out a new Auctioneer Suite that includes the AucDB parts for uploading data and displaying the offline data (whatever part it is that shows average sell prices as that's the part that seems most useful that isn't already part of Auctioneer). Then make it noticeable. Either include a notice on the download page (in big bright letters or something to get attention) or in the addon itself that tells users it's there and what it does. If you don't want to include it in the Auctioneer Suite, then put download and description information everywhere you have download and description information for Auctioneer and Gatherer. Advertise it everywhere you can. And provide detailed explanations of what it is and why it's useful and how to use it.

    We just either didn't know about it at all or didn't know enough of about it to use it. That's the downfall with it. Fix that and any bugs that may be in the system and it may become popular.

    Also, notice that the AucDB forum links are barely even on the page at 1680x1050 without scrolling. It's below development and other links that aren't really much interest to most people. If I am seeing what is available in a "menu" like that, I tend to stop looking once I start seeing development, contact info, etc. (things that aren't the focus of whatever site I'm looking at -- in this case the main addons). I just stop looking at that point and I think many do the same thing. If you moved it up to just under either Auctioneer or Gatherer, you'd likely get more notice here as well. You still need better advertisement elsewhere, but that is at least something easy to do right here. I know you do have it on the tabs at the top (not called AuctioneerDB though), but those tabs are small and not really noticeable at high resolutions. It's rarely a good idea to put navigation tabs at the very top of a page like that as most people tend to ignore anything more than 1/2" to 1" from the top other than a large font title or image.
  •  
    The biggest problem with it (as previously mentioned) are that its a pain to install, and does not have the same "idiot proof" instiallation that most addons do (put this addon folder here and you are done).

    Secondly I was using it for a while, but it was not up to date. The reason I liked wowecon and have been using them since the start is that they MANUALLY had 1 character on each server (1 for alliance and horde) from day one, and would actually sit there and scan the AH for you. Same with WoWheads database when it first began. They actually hired people to track down info and scan AH prices.

    If you could get a few fellow members to scan on a regular basis, it would be great.

    The other problem is that AucDB offline UI is horrible, and 9/10 times does not display the proper data, or in a fashion that we are used to. (I have tried time and time again using it)
    •  
      CommentAuthorMattBnr
    • CommentTimeOct 6th 2009
     
    actually wowecon uses the data from your mail sells. it doesn't use the ah data. it uses what you actually sell the items for to collects data from what i understand about it.
    • CommentAuthoraleinss
    • CommentTimeOct 6th 2009
     
    I just kicked you some greenbacks. I have no interest in the online database (sorry), but I am very interested in the continued development of Auctioneer and Gatherer for all upcoming patches and expansions. Please keep it going!
    • CommentAuthormacker
    • CommentTimeOct 6th 2009
     
    Have to say, like many, I'm a bit saddened to hear the news.

    I think AuctioneerDB (AucDB) is a great idea, and a tremendous benefit to serious players that spend significant time at the AH. For that matter, the entire Auctioneer suite is an incredible project, and the value of it is hard to quantify.

    A quick note, before I start speaking at length. The 100 visitors a day is a measure of visitors to the web UI, correct? This does not account for in-game AucDB module use? I would expect the in-game module use to far exceed that of the web front-end, by at least a factor of 10. Hard to measure whether the in-game use is "active" use, but I'd imagine it's substantial.

    I do completely understand the hosting costs issue, and find it hard to imagine that it would be viable as a free-for-everyone service long-term. I had considered an AucDB like service early on, before such a design was announced on the main site, and always assumed that it would be hosted by guilds, but this would typically be realm-specific. Doing it across all realms is so much more lofty of a goal, with so much more benefit.

    The web interface seems very useful, but to a much more select group of people. As-is, the amount of data yielded by Auctioneer is likely to be very confusing to a vast majority of "general" users. I think the average WoW player is going to be looking primarily at the "moving price" field almost exclusively. To this end, the AucDB in-game add-on gives extended value for the occasional player, who doesn't perform AH scans frequently.

    But for the serious party, be they someone who plays the AH heavily, or who is just interested in the WoW economy, the sampling rate afforded by AucDB is the key to its value. And I do believe that value can be considered in a monetary fashion.

    Collecting the data is always going to cost money; incoming bandwidth is no more free than outgoing bandwidth. Relying on donations for hosting costs, well, if it breaks even, that'd be great. But I'm not expecting that it ever will. So, a few thoughts...

    What is the largest hosting costs for this project? If a significant portion is egress (data delivered to clients), can the amount of data be reduced, while still being useful for the majority of players?

    Is it practical to leverage mirroring by guilds for specific realms, to reduce bandwidth costs?

    Premium ("mandatory donation"/subscription) access to some data? E.g. basic access is 15 minute delayed, up to 2 weeks of detailed history.

    Clearly, there's going to be "commercial users" who benefit from this data. Rather than attempting to block their use, let them pay a commercial level fee, for access/use of data.


    Basically, my objective would be to collect full data from all users, and return basic data to all users, free of charge. Subsidize that by charging for more in-depth access, with tiers of access; average "serious" player may only be looking for detailed info on a per-realm basis, while a "commercial user" will want detailed info for all realms. If it pays for itself, then everyone wins.

    There's definitely some moral questions here, e.g. whether you feel commercial use of the data should not be accepted/condoned. That said, I wouldn't have an objection to it, so long as the use is read-only. I don't see it creating an unfair advantage. I do see the "basic" functionality as aiding all users, and if anything, helping to stabilize the WoW economy. Only people I see losing on that front, are AH players who RP as hedge fund managers.
    • CommentAuthorJase
    • CommentTimeOct 8th 2009
     
    Don't be discouraged.
    The product has suffered from a poor first release.
    Both the database and certainly the documentation were not ready for prime time....and so the market stayed away in droves.
    I never was sure that I was using it correctly and there was no way to find out.
    I certainly didn't understand how to write queries to generate the reports.
    I didn't know what I didn't know. i.e. just what magical gems this could produce for me if I only knew how to work it.
    so I too wandered off....

    Auctioneer works for me and I can see the value it generates....so i donate.
    If the next DB release is sufficiently user friendly that people can experience, through use, what it can do for them....then you should be able to attract a subscription base.
    I will certainly subscribe....but only if its usable and I get value from it.

    I really think this could be self supporting.
    It needs a working program, lots more documentation and some user-friendly stuff e.g. some prepackaged queries....stuff that I don't have the smarts to conceive let alone execute,
    together with a thoughtful, tiered subscription program.

    Build it...and they will come.
    • CommentAuthorOnyx
    • CommentTimeOct 8th 2009
     
    Think the DB is a good idea, but if nobody is using it or not enough people are donating to keep it going there's no point really. I've personally not been very much aware of the existance of AuctDB and how/where to use it, even as a longtime Auctioneer user. Like others noted, this is clearly a marketing issue.

    Btw, you could probably build some sort of shareware mechanism into auctioneer. Basic suite for free, AuctDB functionality for those that pay a small amount of cash. I for one would pay, maybe not for AuctDB perse, but to support the project in general like I've done before. It's not like we can't miss a couple of dollars after all.

    If not enough people are intested it makes sense to just ditch it. No point in wasting your personal cash.

    Onyx.
    • CommentAuthorMarkov
    • CommentTimeOct 8th 2009
     
    I wasn't aware of this aspect of Auctioneer, but I can't even use Auctioneer to its fullest power- mainly because I don't have the time or interest. I use it and it works for my needs. I appreciate all your work. Just wanted to tell you that.

    I'm sure you will make your best call on AucDB.

    Markov
    • CommentAuthorUrythmic
    • CommentTimeOct 9th 2009 edited
     
    Like most it seems, I had no idea there was a web site corresponding to AucDB. I use the AucDB data within Auctioneer all the time. It's the only good way I know to figure out whether the pricing on something is reasonable or not -- the local pricing trends get skewed up or down far too often, so AucDB is crucial.

    The web site obviously has not gotten the sort of promotion it deserves. A few months ago I was looking for something exactly like the AucDB web site, but the only site I could find (via a lot of Google searching) was wowecon, which at the time seemed pretty weak. Even now, doing a Google search returns auctioneeraddon.com at the top of the list, followed by wowecon, the curse listing for Auctioneer, etc., but no mention of AucDB on the first page of results (where it deserves to be), nor even in the first five pages of results, which is probably the limit of what most people will look at. Given this, it should not be a surprise that nobody knows about the AucDB web site.

    There are obviously lots of things that could be done to correct this situation. It mostly depends on what your goals are. Perhaps the simplest option would be to pursue a partnership with another popular web site where links into your data would add a lot of value, such as wowwiki or (even better IMO) wowhead. Someone like wowhead might even be willing to run the server for you (if that's a possibility you find interesting).

    Whatever you decide to do, don't just walk away from it. AucDB obviously took a lot of work and it's incredibly useful for those of us who do know about it. If more people knew about it, you'd have a LOT more interest and support for the effort.
  •  
    AucDbSync-windows-2.0.55.398

    Can not perform an upload with it. Crashes during processing with the same error allaei reported 6 days ago, above. I *JUST* downloaded it, so it should be the latest version.

    Apparently nobody else on Muradin-US has had any success, either. Silk Cloth has been seen 0 times.

    I am/was in the process of doing something similar for my guild, but if AuctioneerDB gets working again, and I can use it successfully to get offline auction pricing, and try to get graphs to show cost trend analysis, etc. then I would happily do that.

    If nobody can upload to the database though, then I guess the decision becomes an enforced "shut it down" by virtue of not being able to get data into it.
    •  
      CommentAuthorMattBnr
    • CommentTimeOct 9th 2009
     
    You cant upload to the database due to it being down due to money issues.
    • CommentAuthorUrythmic
    • CommentTimeOct 9th 2009
     
    For what it's worth, I found a thread on the official forums about this discussion and took some time to write up an explanation of why I think AuctioneerDB is so incredibly valuable.

    Here's the link: http://forums.worldofwarcraft.com/thread.html?topicId=20122259094&postId=203089095987&sid=1#15

    I hope it helps in some small way.
    • CommentAuthorlxdengar
    • CommentTimeOct 10th 2009
     
    As someone who is on good terms with a bunch of people who use auctioneer, I took an informal poll.

    Out of 10 users of auctioneer: 2 knew about AuctioneerDB. 1 had tried it and had some issues.

    4 of the people have, or currently work at Blizzard, who love auctioneer and using it.

    Not to put too fine a point on it, but its really been missed.

    Perhaps you should reconsider? I know I'll definitely be donating!
    • CommentAuthordarkorb
    • CommentTimeOct 11th 2009
     
    I've been a long time user of the data that is accessible here and would hate to see anything bad happen with the project. As such I'd like to offer to help if I can - I work for an ISP/Datacenter here in the UK (London to be exact), if you would like a free of charge location/server(s) to host your project let me know (email me through my profile email address).
    • CommentAuthorAminal
    • CommentTimeOct 11th 2009 edited
     
    I'm pretty sure I would die a beggar in the streets if I didn't have this addon. Thanks for all of the hard work you have done. Until today I had never heard of this DB, but I want it; I needs it. :) I am so intrigued by the possibility of having all of that information in an easy to use interface.
    • CommentAuthorAhazi
    • CommentTimeOct 12th 2009
     
    Auctioneer is an invaluable tool to me, and I would definatly donate/subscribe to the Auctioneer DB service.
    • CommentAuthorYetisan
    • CommentTimeOct 12th 2009 edited
     
    I asked around among my guild's auctioneer users and absolutely 0 knew about DB. Having auto updaters like Wowcensus and curse client: they never visit the site. I only learned of it due to me checking the forum as to why there wasn't a update for gather yet (after some patch)
    Also having the uploader working would have helped i think.
    •  
      CommentAuthorMattBnr
    • CommentTimeOct 12th 2009
     
    The uploader is down until norgs decided what to do about the project. That is the main dilemma is the servers cost which is directly related to the uploading of data.
    • CommentAuthorOzroth
    • CommentTimeOct 12th 2009
     
    I didn't know about uploading the data afterwords.

    Since 3.2, my auctioneer stopped working, or complains about macro errors every time I log in--and so I've stopped using it completely. I thought someone else would have reported the error and that Curse would have let me know it was fixed.

    Also, I find the interface confusing. It's a neat application, and I'd like to play with it some more, but don't have the time to learn how to best sell my stuff, what to buy, and what I can get to DE.
    • CommentAuthorMurkon
    • CommentTimeOct 12th 2009
     
    I was searching the forums for something completely unrelated to this when I stumbled across this thread. I really had no idea what AuctioneerDb is and how it was used until I read this thread. I imagine many other Auctioneer users simply don't know about the situation either. I think it would help a lot if Auctioneer or Norganna had their own Facebook and Twitter accounts. It's a very easy way to communicate with your fans. If not, maybe have some kind of built in random reminder about donations in Auctioneer itself. I think the issue would resolve itself quickly if people were just more aware of what's going on.

    I am now eagerly awaiting the return of AuctioneerDb so I can contribute to it. MattBnr said that even a single dollar from everyone would help keep this going. I'm a college student without a lot of spending money but I do pay for WoW. Auctioneer makes WoW so much more enjoyable for me that I will gladly be donating as soon as I can.

    Norganna - thank you for all of your hard work. I am certain that AuctioneerDb will explode (in a good way!) once it gets back on its feet :)
  •  
    Well, I guess since uploading is no longer an option, data is rotting and getting out of date each passing day, and my server in particular has never had an upload (Silk Cloth seen 0 times) (Muradin-US), I can't think of any reason to keep it. I wanted to try to help make it work by doing uploads and sending guildies to the site to do the same, but it appears from the above comments that there is no current plan to allow uploading data again. If the point was "most accurate info", and the data is growing stale, it kinda defeats the purpose, doesn't it?
    •  
      CommentAuthorMattBnr
    • CommentTimeOct 13th 2009
     
    well if you were to read the comments by norgs the servers cost to keep the uploading is costing alot of money which he just doesn't have at this time since no one was using the site it was wasted money. So hes getting comments from people here and if enough people are willing to visit the site and upload the data and contribute to the project then he will continue the servers running. so until all those conditions are met then yes its kinda a moot point to use aucdb.
    • CommentAuthorsarelon
    • CommentTimeOct 13th 2009
     
    Norganna,

    First, thank you for Auctioneer and the work on AuctioneerDb. Now, as for usage of DB...
    1. Didn't know it existed for quite a while.
    2. I heard about it and it took 10 minutes of searching to find the basically-hidden link. As I type this I'm still trying to find all the pieces I need to make it work.
    3. When I did find it, it was broke. The info on the forums basically said "It's broke and we don't know when it will be up"
    4. Just tried it again and am getting the same error:
    Warning:
    Unexpected exception caught
    Message:
    Error in AddByte(CacheItem39232Slot): value (71245) exceeds byte size
    So basically, either I'm not doing something right and the documentation provided hasn't assisted me in fixing it or something is broken on your end. Either way, the reason why I'm not using the system is hopefully apparent now...
    • CommentAuthoreiy
    • CommentTimeOct 13th 2009 edited
     
    First off, I love Auctioneer. I think it's an amazing product.

    I love the idea of AucDB. However, like many, I didn't know about it for a long time. Then when I found out and tried to use it, I couldn't make it work.

    Question: any reason not to build the sync program directly into Auctioneer? Seems to me that way you'll get the usage automatically, and would be the best way to keep the data up to date.
    •  
      CommentAuthorMattBnr
    • CommentTimeOct 13th 2009 edited
     
    the data is not the problem. the problem, is money right now. the cost to visit ratio just isn't worth it from what i can tell. i believe people were using the program but not enough to support the cost at which it was operating.

    Posted By: NorgannaI have sunk quite a bit of my own time and money (2 years of my spare time, and around $5000 of my own money at this point) into the project to find out that almost nobody is going to use it. We got during the peak of it's use about 100 visitors/day.


    If he/we/us/everyone can get more people visiting the site and using the product then he might be able to justify the money sink for the server.

    Now when you compare that to Auctioneers visits a day to just Curse alone: Avg Daily DL (last 30 days): 7,650 the difference is quite astonishing really. That's not even counting all the visits to the main site we have and the Wowinterface site downloads either.
    • CommentAuthoreiy
    • CommentTimeOct 13th 2009 edited
     
    I see. I guess not too many people know about AuctioneerDB, period.

    For the record I would be happy to donate and support AuctioneerDB, because I think you guys made an awesome product in Auctioneer and I have high hopes for AuctioneerDB. I do have a few comments/suggestions:

    1. I think you should fold the synchronization engine into Auctioneer Suite and promote the DB website in all these other sites (Curse, WoWWiki, etc.). People don't know about AuctioneerDB.

    2. Have you considered providing links to the AuctioneerDB site within the Auctioneer UI? Something like "Check the latest data on the DB website" for users who wants the latest and greatest info without having to wait for data import to complete.

    3. Put a PayPal donate button on all your pages, especially all of AuctioneerDB pages. I was just there and couldn't really figure out how to donate. Most people don't spend a lot of time figuring out how to donate money. Make it really easy for them (1-click).

    4. Can the realm list be sorted? The search UI is a bit hard to use because the realm list is not sorted. Better yet, provide a similar UI as the Auction House for user's to easily find the item they are looking for.

    5. Also, think the main AuctioneerDB site needs a bit facelift. It looks so different from the main Actioneer page that I wasn't sure the two sites were done by the same people (or even related). Auctioneer has a great reputation. You should leverage it.

    6. Finally, the data is not up to date. But I guess you know this one. :)

    Good luck. I do hope to see this project continue. I think it's a very admirable effort and I would love to see it become the most successful WoW AH DB.

    P.S. do you differentiate between donations for Auctioneer vs. for AuctioneerDB? Or do all donations go into supporting both?
    •  
      CommentAuthordinesh
    • CommentTimeOct 14th 2009
     
    sync won't likely ever be in the auc suite, i would guess.

    running the sync requires an executable, which many people are (rightly) concerned about. i doubt we will ever distribute our addons along with an executable, to ensure no one ever feels unsafe about downloading auctioneer itself.
    • CommentAuthorApaseall
    • CommentTimeOct 14th 2009
     
    When an addon like auc-adv is loaded by the wow client as the toon enters the world we get some text letting us know that addon has loaded.
    Is it possible to get a similar message when we log out of a toon ?
    If so then a reminder to upload your data would be good.

    Also:
    If no one was visiting and uploading data then there was not a cost associated with that. I guess the cost was to availability to upload if we wanted to.
    Donations cannot be something that the user has to search to do. Donate options must be in your face such that you ignore them if you like.

    People are lazy and every one lies.
    If you want people to use this then they have to know about it.
    Or to put it another way, if you are wondering if you should bother to continue with the DB project what parameters are you looking at to make your desicion?
    If your metric is the footfall/visit and no one is visiting there are two conclusions to be drawn.
    People don't want to use it. Or there is some other issue including but not limited to; people are not aware it exists, they cannot work out how to use it or it does not do what they want it to.

    You are not getting 100 posts in this thread per day. Since 100 hits to the DB website was not enough to keep it running what is the point of continuing this thread?
    You have already been told why it failed from our point of view.
    No one is going to tell you more flaws. Someone has even offered free hosting.

    ••CommentAuthordarkorb
    •CommentTime2 days ago
    quote
    I've been a long time user of the data that is accessible here and would hate to see anything bad happen with the project. As such I'd like to offer to help if I can - I work for an ISP/Datacenter here in the UK (London to be exact), if you would like a free of charge location/server(s) to host your project let me know (email me through my profile email address).
    • CommentAuthordarkorb
    • CommentTimeOct 14th 2009 edited
     
    I did indeed offer and that offer still stands - I'm sure I can spare 1/2/3/4 servers as needed for a worthwhile project like this - Of course, it's up to them they want to take the offer :)

    By the way, on the subject of using a EXE to upload the data - wowhead use one and people don't seem to have an issue with that... I'd have thought that would be an ideal way of doing it as you could have it run in system tray and pop a little balloon message when a user closes WoW asking them to click to upload the data. Configurable of course :)
    •  
      CommentAuthordinesh
    • CommentTimeOct 14th 2009
     
    thanks for the offer. i did pass it on to norgs, but he hasn't been around in a few days.

    i'm not disputing that an EXE is the best/only way to update data, i'm saying that we wouldn't want to bundle an exe along with our addon. wowhead can get away with it, because that is the whole point of their addon. ours can (and has) been used for in-game reasons only for 4+ years now. I'm not saying that things might not change, but we have historically put a pretty high value on saying that we're only distributing Lua code which cannot, on its own, be used to convey any viruses.
    • CommentAuthordarkorb
    • CommentTimeOct 14th 2009
     
    Ah I see your point :)
    • CommentAuthorXit
    • CommentTimeOct 14th 2009
     
    wonder if the upload could be handled with a simple script. just have it ftp the specified lua files to the server which could then batch process it. The exe currently does some processing of it's own that could be passed off onto the server. Then, if a user is concerned about what the "upload program" is doing, they could just look at it in an editor of their choosing. Would require a script for each os though (win/mac/linux). I could write the linux (bourne shell) version pretty easily.
    • CommentAuthorLorini
    • CommentTimeOct 14th 2009
     
    Hi, I'm hoping auctioneerdb continues, as I'd like to use the data in a web site I'm planning. I donated $25 for this month, but I could give more next month if no disasters occur to my budget :)
    •  
      CommentAuthorMattBnr
    • CommentTimeOct 14th 2009
     
    Thank you every little bit helps.
    • CommentAuthorGorlum
    • CommentTimeOct 15th 2009
     
    I try to used it several times and... it simple didn't work. I'm Russian-speaking user and playing on Russian realms. Import in current ECLI version of AucDB importer didin't work - it's stops in the middle of import process so I even can't contribute. Server data is loose - and I undestand why. If improter didn't work on me I presume it didn't work on someone else. On most active players with large scandata.
    • CommentAuthorJadecomm
    • CommentTimeOct 15th 2009
     
    The questions I have are:

    What is the relationship between Auctioneer and AuctioneerDB?
    Does one depend on the other?
    Will Auctioneer be effected if AuctioneerDB is discontinued?

    Still not sure of the value of AuctioneerDB for the casual player, but find Auctioneer a very useful addon. Is the usefulness of the Auctioneer addon in jeopardy?

    If AuctioneerDB goes away, will the DB download file used to update Auctioneer still be available? If not, what effect will that have on Auctioneer?

    -- Jadecomm
    •  
      CommentAuthordinesh
    • CommentTimeOct 15th 2009 edited
     
    As I said above, there is no danger to Auctioneer proper. This is entirely concerning auctioneerdb, which is a separate addon/out-of-game utility. aucdb does interact with auctioneer, but without it auctioneer will continue to function as it did for many years before aucdb was released.
    • CommentAuthorRAZIM
    • CommentTimeOct 15th 2009 edited
     
    Have there been any intentions of collaborating with any of the players in the WoW database website market (curse, zam, etc.)?

    This may give it a better chance to collect the info and make this portion of the mod more popular. Instead of just another 3rd party app to run it could be integrated into an data grabbing app that site uses already.
    This would probably also off-load much of the data hosting costs. Due to the popularity of Auctioneer I would imagine they'd jump at the chance to be part of auc:db.
    • CommentAuthorcaliber
    • CommentTimeOct 16th 2009
     
    I love my Auctioneer addon, but i have to admit I didn't really know anything about AuctioneerDB. I saw the references to it and always thought it was just part of Auctioneer. There is so much in included in the suite I sort of assumed it was some advanced feature I didn't use.
    • CommentAuthorjwmsd1
    • CommentTimeOct 16th 2009 edited
     
    I downloaded the addon and at first I did not understand how it worked until I took the time, approximately an hour, to read the help and instructions. Now I love the addon it helps me auction items at the correct price and I am making good sales. Before I was losing money because I did not use the features as refresh, scan and several others. Sadly I am unable to donate to keep the addon up and running at this time. I can donate my time to assist with writing instructions and technical documetation, things of that nature. The addon is a great asset to anyone playing WOW. Just take the time to read the help and set it up to your needs you will not be let down.
    • CommentAuthorskad4life
    • CommentTimeOct 16th 2009
     
    As many others I also didn't understand what auctioneerdb was about. I have been using Auctioneer for about a half year (since I started playing the game) and because of it, using the WoW auction house is one of my favorite things to do in game. However, as many before me stated, I too thought auctioneerdb was a database that Auctioneer used.

    Personally I don't think I would be using a searchable web database. For one I don't really see the point, and secondly I don't think the data would ever be accurate enough to be that useful, or it would at least take a very long time. However, if other people would have use for it, I'd be happy to upload data on a regular basis, as I spend quite a bit of time at the AH.
    •  
      CommentAuthorMattBnr
    • CommentTimeOct 16th 2009
     
    if everyone uploaded then the data would be very reliable actually. plus it can go toward your market price so you have a more reliable data to go off. if nothing else its another sanity check to see how YOUR prices are stacking up against the overall of the realm.
    •  
      CommentAuthorNorganna
    • CommentTimeOct 16th 2009
     
    This weekend, I'll spend some time getting the upload exe back up and running.

    We'll give it another try, but I really think that we're gonna need some promotion in order to make sure people know about it.

    Some people mentioned that I should do the scanning of all the auction houses myself. I don't have a whole heap of money to create a bunch of accounts and manually scan 844 auction houses. I would need 17 accounts (50 max chars per account) to do this, and it would take approximately 9 days non-stop to create the accounts and run them to the auction house. It would take me approximately 2 days non-stop to scan all the auction houses. It simply isn't feasible for me to do this.

    So if this is going to be done, I think I'll need help to scan the extra auction houses at least at the start. I'll work on a page where the currently absent realms are listed, and if some of you guy/girls could spare some time to go into an extra realm once a day/week and do a scan, we can get at least some data for the missing realms, I think that this would help fill in the gaps.

    It may even be a fun exercise to create a new Level 1 char (or possibly DK) in a new realm and try and "start-up" from scratch. I know I enjoy doing this and it's also easier to take bigger risks if all you're doing on that realm is trading, cause it doesn't really affect you as much if you lose everything.

    Of course at some point it will reach critical mass and people will be submitting data for all realms anyhow.
    • CommentAuthorCrelam
    • CommentTimeOct 16th 2009
     
    Perhaps the project simply needs more exposure. Advertisement if you will. I think a piece on the project on one of the larger WoW news sites (wow.com, mmo-champion) would give this a jump.
    • CommentAuthornero
    • CommentTimeOct 16th 2009 edited
     
    I've been waiting for you to get back to us about aucdb! Thanks norganna.

    I agree you just need a bit more exposure and the project will reach critical mass fairly quickly.

    Also, the main reason I would like to see aucdb work, is so I can look at price history and trends. I'm running Market Watcher at the moment, which does give me a graphical history of prices, but only for select items, as it is too intensive to keep data for much more than a few items. But it's eye opening looking at some of the trends. There are specific items that consistently dive in price on Saturday morning, and then skyrocket that afternoon.

    If you can get the Db back and accepting data, I will surely be uploading mine, and if I can spare some coin, will donate what I can.

    Nero
    *edit* Totally happy to go crazy on the DK idea and get a bunch of DKs on other realms uploading data for you. I could do that starting phase 50 times before I got bored of it...
  •  
    Rox! I haven't read all the posts but thanks for not giving up on Auc-DB quite yet. I think it has the potential to be much bigger than wowecon (I upload to both most of the time). And yes I agree people need to learn about it more etc. I dl'ed DB data once when it said it was old, and only really paid attention to it when someone mentioned it on another site. Before that I went straight to the dl page.

    Creating alts is a great idea. I like feeling like I'm contributing, even if it's just a small help to something that isn't that big (not putting down global WoW databases or the people who work on them, it's just not on the same level as, for example, the goals of Doctors Without Borders or Responsible Policies for Animals), and I currently run WarcraftRealms' Census+ (and KillingFields when I PvP although I almost never do) too.

    It's a good opportunity to not go out of my way to scan multiple realms, because I've been thinking about moving my ally toon to a PST Seattle server anyway, so I've been running alts to the AH and scanning them (and the /who with Census+) when I can.

    I think humans have by far the easiest time getting to an AH at level 1 btw. It's a very short, safe run (make higher hp class or you might die running through Defias, I've died with humans a total of 3x making 11 of them usually with random classes like priest), with really 1 place you really have to turn so autorunning doesn't take much attention. I complained it was unfair, and my partner said to think of it as another racial bonus. UD probably is easiest on horde side, but they look so painful I don't like looking at them, so I go with my second choice, BE.

    The downside is that my Auc-ScanData is about 170mb now :( I'm going to have to kill data for other realms, back up the files for my main realms and delete them (Auc-DB is so small it can handle all the realms for now I think), then start new files for non-main realms, kill their files, restore my main data, repeat...but it's better than getting horrible fps, etc from it eating so much memory when I'm playing.
    • CommentAuthorkezmoo
    • CommentTimeOct 17th 2009 edited
     
    Yay! XD

    I've mentioned AucDB to quite a few people, who've all said they'd love to try it if it were working, so now I can go tell them the good news! I'm in agreement with others, if we can get AucDB the exposure it needs (and deserves!) there's no reason why it shouldn't be a runaway success!

    Also, as a bit of an altoholic, I'm more than willing to create alts on the under-represented servers (EU only, but willing to attempt all langs!), to make sure you get all the data you need :)

    (oh, and I've always found it easiest to get to Orgrimmar as a lvl 1 Hordie)
    • CommentAuthorSouthO
    • CommentTimeOct 18th 2009
     
    I can sponsor the bandwidth and help with some servers.
    • CommentAuthorjfharford
    • CommentTimeOct 18th 2009
     
    I am intrigued by AucDB idea which I never understood until now. I want to try it out and if it has promise, understanding that "critical mass" has yet to be achieved, I will make a contribution. I just now downloaded it as part of the 5.7 Auctioneer Suite but got stuck when the install instructions directed me to http://us.auctioneerdb.com/ to "install" it. I'm not sure exactly what this step is for, but I find nothing on that page relating to the AucDB addon as far as I can tell. So I'm stuck.

    Is it me, or is AucDB no longer available? If it is me, I am sure there are others like me who have just given up at this point. Thanks for your attention, and best of luck.
    • CommentAuthorkrick
    • CommentTimeOct 18th 2009
     
    The biggest problem I see with AuctioneerDB is that it's not easy to use. There should be an application that runs in the windows system tray that will upload data automatically when you exit WoW. The current application has no installer and needs to be run manually. Neither is very user friendly. I use WoWEcon and I think that AuctioneerDB could certainly borrow some ideas from it.

    The other problem is what people in this thread have mentioned... visibility. Very few people know that AuctioneerDB even exists. It needs to be more tightly linked to and integrated with Auctioneer.

    Finally, I'm having an issue with the AuctioneerDB site where it won't let me register my client. I'm trying to use my forum name and password but it keeps rejecting it. If other people are having this problem, it might account for the low adoption rate.
    • CommentAuthoreiy
    • CommentTimeOct 19th 2009 edited
     
    I am very glad to hear that you will give AuctioneerDB another try. I am happy to create accounts in other realms to help scanning the data.

    BTW, does auctioneer scan all 3 auction chains (alliance, horde, and neutral)? Or do you have to be at the auction house of the chain to get the data?
    •  
      CommentAuthordinesh
    • CommentTimeOct 19th 2009
     
    you have to go to each and scan manually.
    •  
      CommentAuthorsdmarine
    • CommentTimeOct 20th 2009
     
    I'm a great admirer of all Norganna's addons and have been using them for quite some awhile. They've certainly gotten better with each new revision and I'd hate to see them go away. I'll be making another donation to assist with the cause, and urge other players in my guild that use your addons to do the same. Best of luck, and God bless.

    Semper Fidelis,
    Kerry

    Saepius Exertus, Semper Fidelis, Frater Infinitas - Often tested, Always faithful, Brothers forever - United States Marines
    • CommentAuthorSchweppesX
    • CommentTimeOct 20th 2009
     
    Wow! AuctioneerDB will be online again! I'm so happy. Let's me first finish reading this long thread and I will reply what I will do to help. I have lots of ideas how to make AuctioneerDB successful and I personally want (and can) help.
    • CommentAuthoreiy
    • CommentTimeOct 21st 2009
     
    Is the page of missing realms available, yet? I am ready to start helping out.

    Also, when do you think the updated client will be done? I am manually uploading/downloading the database right now. Would love to test out the newly fixed client.
    •  
      CommentAuthorMattBnr
    • CommentTimeOct 21st 2009
     
    I think this weekend hes gonna get it up and going. maybe. lets hope.
  •  
    About the future of the Auctioneer.
    To start, I'd like to say that I am a new Auctioneer user, myself and am loving it. When i found this site, and read the news posts, i was really disappointed that the DB would be taken down. I also know a few people who use it and recommend it to me and felt the same. There is, however a very common problem I find with my friends (and im ashamed to say, even myself) is that a lot of the Auctioneer functions we/they cant seem to learn to use. Im sure that throughout a lot of your forums, I could find a lot of the answers to questions, but if you know gamers, they're lazy. Even if you don't revise the interface, maybe just make a detailed tutorial vid about how to use Auctioneer.

    For Advertising, you might be able to ask some of the Guilds who use your mod to advertise on their sites.
  •  
    Any word on the new client yet? I have been following the manual upload instructions, but even after doing that a couple times, there is still no data for my server, which is surprising. Also, Is Norganna going to take up the now 2 offers to host / sponsor the hosting and bandwidth for the auctioneerDB site? This should significantly drop the cost of maintaining the site.

    Yay on taking another shot at it. I need to read more of the docs.
    • CommentAuthorHaroldnca
    • CommentTimeOct 22nd 2009
     
    I was just listening to "The Instance" podcast and they had a very good idea for AuctioneerDB. Create an iPhone app. I would use it constantly if I had access to that data on my iPhone.
    •  
      CommentAuthorNorganna
    • CommentTimeOct 22nd 2009 edited
     
    Just an update:

    I spent a lot of time (practically all of it) over the weekend attempting to get the OS X version of AucDb to compile since I have upgraded to Snow Leopard and it seems the Mono people haven't done any updates for the new OS X yet.

    I did finally manage to get it to compile, but it still doesn't actually run on Snow Leopard, it crashes during the import.

    At this stage, I don't have any option but to put the OS X version on hold until they (Mono) have a working OS X 10.6 compiler/toolset/libraries. (I'll upload the compiled version and see if someone who has 10.5 can run it.)

    I've also written in the changes to the import routine that will allow the importer to download the cache file definition from the server and skip the cache processing if the definition doesn't exist for that version of the WoW client. (in simple terms, no more crashing every time the WoW client updates)

    Work is extremely hectic at the moment. I was hoping to have time to finish it off during the week, but just didn't have time. I expect to have this completed over this coming weekend.
    • CommentAuthorApaseall
    • CommentTimeOct 23rd 2009
     
    Fantastic
    • CommentAuthorVladdy
    • CommentTimeOct 23rd 2009
     
    I personally have no use for a out of game price database.
    • CommentAuthoreiy
    • CommentTimeOct 23rd 2009
     
    Great to hear the updates, Norganna. Thank you for your hardwork.

    Meanwhile, as soon as you tell us what realm/auction houses are missing (ala the page) I will create a character there and start scanning.

    Keep up the good work. Your effort is greatly appreciated.
    •  
      CommentAuthorMattBnr
    • CommentTimeOct 23rd 2009
     
    Posted By: VladdyI personally have no use for a out of game price database.
    This isn't just about out of game prices and databases. Aucdb also provides you prices based upon others that have submitted data to the servers so you get more accurate prices. It takes all the data that has been provided adds them all up and does some wicked math and spits back a very accurate number.
    • CommentAuthorXingYuen
    • CommentTimeOct 24th 2009
     
    So as of right now AuctioneerDB.com is still down for importing right?
    •  
      CommentAuthorMattBnr
    • CommentTimeOct 25th 2009
     
    Yes im sure that norgs will post a update when he has it back up and running.
    • CommentAuthorNeroon
    • CommentTimeOct 26th 2009
     
    As you may recall (or not), when you announced AuctioneerDB - what I said was:

    "What is it?"

    Never heard of it before - and forgot about it later. I think your problem may be one of PR - there might be a lot of people who would be interested if they knew about it, how it worked etc. And NOT by having to spend ages trawling through wikis about something they are not sure is for them - but as quick easy PR blurbs.
    Not that you should be spamming or anything, but perhaps getting it mentioned a bit more here and there would help.
    • CommentAuthorSchweppesX
    • CommentTimeOct 27th 2009
     
    I'm all excited. Can't wait until you fix AuctioneerDB.
  •  
    Hi,

    I've set up a cronjob to upload Auc-Db.lua to http://us.auctioneerdb.com/contribute.php (sorry - I just can't stand GUI apps for simple repetitive tasks). But! - I'm wondering if this is the way to do it. Is there any difference between using the client applications and uploading manually (ie. via the website)?

    I'm using the Perl script found here: http://lena.franken.de/perl_hier/uploadingfiles/index.html . It seems to be working - but can someone on the inside please confirm whether or not this solution is OK? If it works then at least the Linux-users (perhaps also Mac-users) have no excuse for not uploading regularly.

    Regards,
    '79
  • World of Warcraft™ and Blizzard Entertainment™ are trademarks or registered trademarks of Blizzard Entertainment, Inc. in the U.S. and/or other countries.